Aries: Bourbon, Neat
Aries are independent and confident, so they're not worried about someone judging them for their drink order. And ultimately, they want something simple
Taurus: Negroni Sbagliato
Aries are independent and confident, so they're not worried about someone judging them for their drink order. And ultimately, they want something simple
Gemini: French 75
This classic cocktail comes with a pedigree and some historical context, which will delight the cerebral Gemini
Cancer: Piña Colada
Water signs are very sensitive to substances of all kinds," Loftis says, so it's best to "keep it light." Luckily, piña coladas err on the sweet and less-strong side
Leo: Gold Rush
For the discerning Leo, Loftis recommends ordering a Gold Rush, made with bourbon, honey, and fresh lemon juice
Virgo: Sazerac
Virgos are extremely matter-of-fact, which is why they require a nightcap with "very specific ingredients," says Loftis. A Sazerac is made with rye whiskey, a sugar cube, Peychaud's Bitters, and anise liqueur
Libra: Cosmopolitan
Libras are the sophisticated socialites of the zodiac and are no strangers to a night out on the town," says Ash. They love mixing things up and trying new cocktails
Scorpio: Old Fashioned
Loftis encourages Scorpios to opt for a good scotch or whiskey because it's as straightforward as they are
Sagittarius: Margarita
The party doesn't start till Sagittarius walks in, and a margarita is a party in a glass," says Honigman. "This sign likes to have a good time, and this sweet but salty combination is perfect," Loftis adds
Capricorn: Espresso Martini
If you have a Capricorn pal, you've probably seen them order a martini before—and give the bartender extremely specific instructions
Aquarius: Midori Sour
Eccentric and rebellious Aquarians don't want average cocktails. Instead, they should try a Midori Sour, since it's "a quirky green drink for our slightly alien Aquarian friends," says Loftis
Pisces: Paloma
Water sign Pisces should consider ordering a Paloma, made with tequila, grapefruit, and lime juice